Summative and Formative Peer Review for Faculty Growth | Coaching and Consulting
John Minnich offers confidential, summative and formative peer reviews designed to enhance instructional effectiveness, student learning, and faculty development across all teaching modalities. These consultations are ideal for institutions and academic leaders committed to continuous improvement and pedagogical excellence.
Formative peer review offerings (Faculty-Driven, Confidential)
Designed to support faculty development and continuous improvement in a confidential, collegial setting. Focused on improvement and reflective teaching practice, these consultations are entirely confidential and collegial:
- Classroom observation with developmental feedback: Pre‑observation meetings set goals; follow‑up meetings support reflection and actionable planning
- Syllabus and instructional materials review: Feedback aligns course components with learning objectives
- Small Group Instructional Diagnostics (SGID): Structured mid‑semester feedback facilitated in small groups, confidential and developmental only
- Assessment of student learning outcomes: Review of alignment and assessment effectiveness
- Analysis of course evaluations and student feedback: Identifying trends and areas for instructional refinement
- Online course design review using Quality Matters™‑informed standards: A rubric-based evaluation aligned with Online Course Design Standards; includes action planning and prioritization of actionable steps
Formative peer review promotes reflective practice, user-defined goals, and trust-based peer consultation as part of continuous faculty development.
Summative peer review offerings (Reviewer-Driven, Evaluative)
Summative peer reviews are designed to support formal evaluation contexts—such as annual reviews, promotion and tenure decisions, or course facilitation awards. These offerings follow established institutional criteria and produce evaluative reports intended for department chairs, deans, and other academic leaders.
- Classroom observation with evaluative feedback: Focused on instructional effectiveness and alignment with institutional expectations; may include announced or unannounced visits per institutional guidelines
- Syllabus and instructional materials review: Evaluates alignment with course objectives, curricular standards, and accreditation requirements
- Assessment of student learning outcomes: Reviews evidence of student achievement and effectiveness of assessment methods
- Analysis of course evaluations and student feedback: Interprets trends and patterns to assess instructional impact and consistency across sections or semesters
- Online course design review (evaluation-focused): Applies Quality Matters™-informed institutional benchmarks to evaluate course structure, accessibility, and learning engagement
Summative reviews are structured, formal, and shared with academic leadership—distinct from formative reviews, which are confidential and faculty-driven.
Recognized Expertise in Faculty Development
These consultations are grounded in experience as a trained peer reviewer and faculty developer—recognized through institutional leadership roles and a selective appointment as a Doermer Teaching Fellow and CELT Faculty Consultant at Purdue University Fort Wayne. The approach is collegial, tailored, and strategically aligned with your academic goals.
Trusted Voice in Executive Education and National Executive Research
Appointed by expert business faculty colleagues as MBA Policy Chair at Purdue University Fort Wayne—an AACSB-accredited business school—John Minnich has played a key role in shaping the strategic direction of the graduate program while continuing to lead executive advisory efforts focused on executive leadership and financial strategy in business.
Broad Academic and Professional Experience Across Sectors
Throughout his career, John Minnich has served on the business faculty at five colleges and universities and brings substantial professional experience at the local, regional, and national levels. He has held practitioner roles across three CPA firms, served as a systems consultant with a fintech firm, and held the role of CFO.
Founder, Speaker, and Contributor to National Executive Insights
As the Founder of Minnich + Associates, John Minnich brings a strategic advisory lens to every engagement. He is also a national speaker, having presented in numerous states for statewide CPA societies, and has contributed expertise including executive research at the national level.
Empowering Faculty Growth
Support your faculty with expert-driven, high-trust feedback that fosters growth, reflection, and instructional impact.
John Minnich’s approach balances strategic insight with collegial support—helping faculty refine their facilitation practices in a way that’s constructive, personalized, and aligned with institutional goals.
Let’s explore how peer review can elevate teaching and foster faculty growth across our Purdue community.